Fans are surprised the flavor hasn’t appeared on the menu until now.
Crumbl Cookies has introduced a new treat for the week of May 19 through May 24, and many fans are wondering why it took so long to arrive. The brand’s latest addition to its rotating menu is the Chocolate Reese’s Pieces Cookie, a rich chocolate cookie filled with Reese’s Pieces candy.
The new flavor joins the chain’s weekly lineup of creative and seasonal offerings. It’s a surprise to many loyal customers that this peanut butter and chocolate combination has never appeared on Crumbl’s menu before.
In addition to the debut of the Chocolate Reese’s Pieces Cookie, this week’s featured Dessert of the Month is the Tres Leches Cake, a soft, milky sponge cake inspired by the classic Latin dessert.
Here’s the full Crumbl menu for the week of May 19–24:
- Chocolate Reese’s Pieces Cookie (new)
- Tres Leches Cake (Dessert of the Month)
- Confetti Cake
- Lemon Cheesecake Cookie
- Banana Cream Pie Cookie
- Chocolate Crumb Cookie featuring OREO
- Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie
This week’s selection brings a refreshing balance, with several non-chocolate options joining the menu—such as the Banana Cream Pie, Lemon Cheesecake, and the festive Confetti Cake. Fans who prefer lighter, fruitier desserts may find more to love this time around.
Still, for chocolate lovers, the arrival of the Chocolate Reese’s Pieces Cookie is a highlight. Crumbl continues to surprise and delight fans with inventive new flavors each week.
Related topics:
